Pox Americana : The Great Smallpox Epidemic of 1775-82
by Elizabeth A. Fenn

History Book Reviews

Site main index :
Book Reviews - All Categories
 >> Science Books

History and Social Issues
 >> Pox Americana
by Fenn

Please click here to check the price / option to buy :
Pox Americana : The Great Smallpox Epidemic of 1775-82
by Elizabeth A. Fenn

Hardcover - 377 pages
First Edition, October 2001
Published by Hill and Wang
A division of Farrar, Straus and Giroux
ISBN 0-8090-7820-1 / 0809078201

            Pox Americana , by George Washington University history professor Elizabeth A. Fenn tells the story of the effect of smallpox (Variola) on American society and history around the time of the American revolution. As you may know, smallpox was spread in ancient times from Asia and Africa to Greece and Persia, and then to Europe. This new book by Fenn considers only the transmission through the U.S., Mexico, and Canada. It isn't a source book for medical knowledge about the disease, but an insightful account of how the epidemic changed, and might have changed further, the revolutionary struggle and the Native Americans' loss of population and power.

Click to buy the book -- Pox Americana : The Great Smallpox Epidemic of 1775 - 1782 by Elizabeth A. Fenn

            First, a word about the difference between inoculation and vaccination, and how and when the two medical skills were acquired.

            Smallpox inoculation (deliberate infection with the same virus) was discovered long before smallpox vaccination (deliberate infection with a different but related virus).

            Inoculation was part of the tribal knowledge of some African people. Kidnapped Africans taken to North America as slaves inoculated each other in strict secrecy. The white population couldn't figure out why the number of smallpox cases among the slaves was lower than the incidence rate among their enslavers. In 1716, Onesimus, a slave "owned" by Cotton Mather, a Puritan minister in Boston, broke the secret and told his "owner" about the procedure. If one makes a small incision in the arm and deliberately introduces smallpox, the individual usually becomes moderately ill, and only for a short time. Upon recovering, he or she is permanently immune to smallpox. [Fenn, pages 31-32] The inoculation itself has a measureable fatality rate. In 1721, there was an outbreak of smallpox in Boston. The inoculation process itself killed 2 percent of the patients who requested it, while 15 percent of the people who acquired the disease without having been inoculated died from the virus. [33]

            Vaccination, however, was invented in 1796 by James Jenner, a physician in England. In Jenner's experiment, he infected an 8-year-old boy with cowpox. Jenner later tried to give the boy a smallpox inoculation, but was unable to do so, because the infection required to perform an inoculation wouldn't appear. The previous experience with cowpox had made the boy immune to smallpox. Jenner published his results in 1796. [33]

            Due to the dangers of the inoculation, as well as for religious reasons, the process was politically and medically controversial when smallpox spread throughout all of North America during 1775 to 1882, as it was equally controversial in Europe. Many cities banned, or hesitated to adopt, the new procedure of inoculation against smallpox (variolation). The more pragmatic leaders considered the fact that the inoculation itself can kill, and the fact that inoculees who avoided the disease were still capable of transmitting the virus to others. In addition, many of the devoutly religious considered inoculation to be unnatural, a rebellion against the will of God.

Table of Contents

Pox Americana : The Great Smallpox Epidemic of 1775-82 ,
by Elizabeth A. Fenn


   Foreword	 ix
   Introduction    3

   1. Variola	 13
   2. Vigilance   44
   3. Control	 80
   4. Surrender   104
   5. Enterrios   135
   6. Traders	 167
   7. Connections  196
   8. Passages	 224

   Epilogue	259
   Notes       279
   Index       359

            Unlike the leaders of other cities, the authorities in Philadelphia decided not to ban or even regulate the procedure. This decision had several effects. It caused people from other colonies to travel to Philadelphia to seek the inoculation, including Thomas Jefferson and Martha Washington. The market forces of supply and demand made the treatment become very expensive, until it became unavailable to the working class. Most of the victims of the epidemic were the children of the poorest families. The influx of so many visitors also caused the city to have a much greater than average incidence of the disease. [83]

            George Washington was infected in 1751. Based on the incubation period of about 12 days, historians can calculate that he picked up the virus while visiting Barbados. He survived; he did, however, stop writing his diary for 24 days. [15] Having been once infected, he was permanently immune to the virus which later endangered his troops, particularly in Boston. After July 4, 1776, General Washington had to consider the British empire to be the primary enemy, but the virus among his troops was a close second. He made it a direct order for all of his troops to be inoculated, without which decision (as Fenn explains with cogent reasoning) the British force probably would have defeated the Colonial army. He called his inoculation initiative "outflanking the enemy." [82]

            John Adams performed an experiment on himself. He underwent the inoculation treatment, then, to lessen the likelihood that the inoculation would kill him, he consumed a mercury solution to kill the virus. Finally, he had to recover from mercury poisoning. In the end, he was left with every tooth in his mouth being loose, the result of the mercury, but could at least go on with his life with the knowledge that he was immune from smallpox. [33-35]

Editorial Opinion

            "History repeats itself", the philosopher Hegel wrote. Marx added, "First as tragedy, and then as farce."

            Unfortunately, a problem hitherto thought to have become moot becomes timely once again.

            The disease caused by the smallpox virus has been mentioned in written history for more than 3,000 years, but, in 1979, the World Health Organization (WHO) officially certified that smallpox was completely eradicated throughout the world. In 2001, the United States Congress held sessions to study whether the country will be prepared in the event of another smallpox epidemic. The juxtaposition of those two sentences is ironic.

            We made the virus extinct, except for samples retained in vials in laboratory freezers, for possible future research applications. Now those retained samples endanger the human race, particularly if terrorists can find a black market source for purchasing stolen vials. It seems to indicate the folly of international politicians and scientists who decided to retain samples of the otherwise extinct humanity-threatening virus.

            In the event that history does repeat itself, we may gain insight by revisiting the experience of the 1775-1782 epidemic.

Opinion by Mike Lepore
crimsonbird.com editor

  See our feature articles on terrorism  

            The native people of North America were hit hardest by the epidemic. By the 1790s, the tribes along the Missouri River -- the Mandans, Pawnees, and Arikaras -- who lived in crowded agricultural towns, suffered deaths of whole towns. Lewis and Clark, who stayed with the Arikaras for a time, commented in their journals about this diseases which causes the extinction of entire towns. [262] This left these tribes incapable of defending against attacks by the Sioux; hearing of this, the Sioux invaded. However, in the process of invasion, the Sioux were infected also. [217-218] Similarly, it cannot be verified, but it is probable, that the Comanches were infected because they attacked the Apaches.[213]

            The way economics was arranged among the tribes, the epidemic made the Blackfeet more powerful. It had been mandatory for them to acquire the goods of traders by way of middlemen among the Crees and Assiniboines. When smallpox killed the middlemen, the Blackfeet dealt with the traders directly. This provided them with such an abundance of guns and other goods that they took a considerable amount of land away from the Shoshones. [263] The advantage was temporary. The Blackfeet didn't understand the concept of a contagion, as one named Saukamappee later explained, "We had no belief that one man could give it to another, any more than a wounded man could give his wound to another." [221] Therefore, when the disease attacked this tribe as well, there was no explanation but that the Good Spirit had forsaken the people, leaving them at the mercy of the Bad Spirit. [221]

            The illustrations in the book are to a purpose, not merely to decorate. The map on page 7 indicates the documented paths (solid arrows) and probable paths (dotted arrows) of the travels of the virus from Mexico City to northern Canada. A map on page 216 shows the Shoshone-Comanche trade routes. The table on page 19 cross references days to communicability and symptoms. Page 274 tabulates mortality rates for ethnic groups, e.g., the Ojibwas, and for places, e.g., Wilmington, North Carolina. In all, there are 38 black & white illustrations.

Reviewed by Mike Lepore for
crimsonbird.com

            The appendix of notes provides a full set of references to primary sources, fact-by-fact, following scholarly style.

            12-page 2-column index.

Please click here for price and shipping information ...
Pox Americana : The Great Smallpox Epidemic of 1775-82 , by Elizabeth A. Fenn

Book Description
From the Publisher

          During the years when the Revolutionary War transformed thirteen former British colonies into a new nation, a horrifying epidemic of smallpox was transforming -- or ending -- the lives of tens of thousands of people across the American continent. This great pestilence easily surpassed the war in terms of deaths, yet because of our understandable preoccupation with the Revolution and its aftermath, it has remained virtually unknown to us. Elizabeth A. Fenn is the first historian to reveal how deeply Variola affected the outcome of the War of Independence, and why it caused a continental epidemic, affecting the lives of virtually everyone in North America from Florida to Alaska.

          Political ferment and military actions helped to spark the initial outbreaks of the dreaded illness on the East Coast, where the pox struck first in Boston. As the contagion of liberty spread, this gruesome contagion of pestilence spread with it, striking Native Americans, Continental soldiers, and settlers of both European and African descent. Smallpox devastated the American troops in Quebec and kept them at bay during the British occupation of Boston. Soon the disease affected the war in Virginia, where it ravaged slaves who had escaped to join the British forces. And during the terrible winter at Valley Forge, General Washington had to decide if and when to attempt the risky inoculation of his troops.

          In 1779, while Creeks and Cherokees were dying in Georgia, the pox broke out in Mexico City, whence it followed travelers north, striking Texas and then erupting in Santa Fe and outlying pueblos in January 1781. From there the epidemic ravaged the northern plains and wrought havoc among the Indians trading furs at the Hudson Bay. Simultaneously, it reached the Pacific coast and extended to what is now southeastern Alaska. Fenn argues persuasively that not only the war but the expansion of the European world economy -- and with it the acquisition of the horse by plains Indians; the increase in intertribal conflict aggravated by access to guns; the trade in furs and other goods; the Spanish pattern of colonization, missionization, and silver mining -- created the circumstances for this unprecedented continental epidemic.

          The destructive, desolating power of smallpox made for a cascade of public-health crises and heart-breaking human drama. Fenn explores the many different ways this megatragedy was met, and analyzes the consequences. Her brilliant book is a signal contribution to the study of infectious diseases which immensely increases our understanding of the interplay between devastating pestilence and historical change. And it transforms our picture of the American Revolution.

Please click here to check the price at Amazon.com ...
Pox Americana : The Great Smallpox Epidemic of 1775-82 , by Elizabeth A. Fenn
ISBN 0-8090-7820-1 / 0809078201

Site main index :
Book Reviews - All Categories
 >> Science Books

History and Social Issues
 >> Pox Americana
by Fenn